Two distinguished academicians – Robert Burgelman of Stanford University and Adam Kingl London Business School answer queries from readers on Advanced Management Programmes
Query: If you look at most of the AMP sessions, they are based on strategy per se – the ‘how’ and ‘what’ of it. That is strategy for the sake of strategy-making. But strategy needs to be taught from a practitioner's point of view that covers all managerial functions. I think this is where AMPs lack. What they follow is the import of Porter-Kaplan gifts to strategy framework. This is why organisations face strategy-execution dilemmas. I think strategy gurus should focus their research on the "why", ‘how’ and ‘what’ of strategy. I would like to pass my question to Prof Robert Burgelman. What does your experience say about that? - Amulya Pokhrel
Adam Kingl
I could never assume that an AMP programme like our Accelerated Development Programme (ADP) at London Business School is right for everyone in all circumstances. That's why we have an application and interview for all candidates: to make sure it's the right programme for the right person at the right time. So without knowing why you're considering something like like the ADP and knowing your background in more detail, I couldn't answer with certainty. That said, many people do an AMP instead of an MBA because it is ultimately less time and money, and at London Business School they still earn alumni status. That network at the very least is useful no matter what throughout one's career.
I think a CXO or CXO-aspirant would benefit from an AMP because a CXO needs to understand a business holistically in order to represent all the company's interests to multiple stakeholders. As far as the programme cost, I would argue that everything is relative - as you might have expected! Unlike many academic subjects, business faculty are in extremely short supply throughout the world. As a scarce resource, they are well compensated. So it's impossible to cost programmes, as one might for a further education course in, say, Literature or Art. In addition, most AMPs costs include accommodation and meals, and are cheaper than doing an MBA, not to mention the time saved.
Robert Burgelman:
According to programme alumni, we know the value gained from AMPs far outweighs the tuition invested. Past participants report that AMPs provide a transformational experience so that executives return to their organisations with breakthrough insights and actionable plans to drive results. Executives — even those with an MBA degree — are often focused so intensively on their day-to-day operations they develop tunnel vision. Attending an AMP enables them to quickly survey today’s global, highly competitive and dynamic business landscape, and update their core management skills accordingly. In addition, the best AMPs provide networking opportunities among peers to facilitate idea exchange and to share best practices. The wide range of functions, industries, and countries represented by the diverse mix of participants in these types of programs provides exposure to valuable new perspectives on management that cannot be gained “on the inside”.